Which Toaster Oven Makes the Best Toast?

Toasted bread tastes wonderful. But you require a toaster oven that yields the best toasting result to realize how much you were missing out on as far as toasting bread goes. Of course, toaster ovens come in different models, and they are in plenty.

And you will want to pick the best one since you also want value for money. First, you want to ensure your preferred toaster oven features the toasting function among other cooking programs. Second, you also want to pick a toaster oven with EvenToast technology for uniformly toasted bread. A toaster oven that serves you for many years is also an excellent choice.

But with many toaster ovens on the market, finding the best models might be a little challenging. That’s why we have rounded up some of the best toaster ovens yielding the best toasting results. Also, we have included a buyer’s guide to help you know what to look for when shopping. So, be sure to read on for more information.

Top Picks for The Toaster Ovens for The Best Toast

Toshiba AC25CEW-BS Toaster Oven

This Toshiba toaster oven makes one of the best toasts since it cooks with sufficient power. With a 1,500-Watt rating, this toaster oven delivers heat ranging from 150°F to 450°F. Once you have selected your cooking program, this toaster oven preheats in a short time to get itself ready to cook your meal. As such, it is an energy-efficient toaster oven.

It boasts ten cooking functions with the toasting setting among the cooking programs. The other cooking programs include Bake, Broil, Pizza, Cookies, Defrost, Reheat, Rotisserie, Keep warm, and Convection. It offers flexibility as you can cook many food types in your toaster oven.

Thanks to its convection and rotisserie settings, this toaster oven roasts chicken to deliver the best cooking result. And that’s because the convection setting locks in all the flavors while cooking the chicken with even heat. And the result? A tender and juicier meal.

It has a large cooking capacity equivalent to 25 liters. You can toast up to six slices of bread and bake a 12-inch pizza besides roasting a whole chicken in this extra-large cooking interior. Cleaning the cooking interior is easy, and you can clean the removable accessories once they have cooled off.

It has control dials for the temperature, function, and cooking time. Also, there is an intuitive LCD screen display to guide you through the settings. With its high temperature accuracy and digital controls, this toaster oven toasts the bread slices to deliver the browning you desire.

ProsCons
1,500W cooking power.It has no air fry function.
Convection fan.It has no automatic shutoff.
Extra-large capacity.
Best Toaster Oven Reviews

Cuisinart TOB-40N Custom Classic Toaster Oven

This Cuisinart is a more powerful toaster oven with 1,800W cooking power. With such powerful cooking power, you can only expect this unit to heat to higher temperatures. And it does an incredible job of heating to temperatures ranging from 200°F to 500°F. As such, it covers all the temperatures for cooking all foods in your cookbook.

It also boasts a generous cooking capacity as it boasts a 0.50 cubic foot cooking interior. You can fit an 11-inch pizza stone and bake pizza or warm your frozen pizza. Also, you could roast a 3 lbs. chicken and toast six slices of bread. It is a perfect choice for users with a larger family.

One incredible feature of this toaster oven is the EvenToast shade control. The unit has a control knob dedicated to helping you select one of three toast shades: light, medium, and dark. Whichever shade you choose, your bread will toast evenly, thanks to the EvenToast technology. Therefore, this toaster oven delivers one of the best toasts.

It also features other cooking functions besides toasting your bread slices. These cooking functions include bagel, bake, broil, and warm. Therefore, it is a multi-functional kitchen appliance that cooks any food in your kitchen space. The auto-out feature makes removing the removable crumb tray and other accessories from the toaster oven a complete breeze, even if the accessories are still hot. It has everything you need to have the best toast for breakfast.

ProsCons
1,800W cooking power.No convection technology.
EvenToast Technology.It has no oven light.
Extra-large cooking capacity.
Best Toaster Oven Reviews

Hamilton Beach 2-in-1 Countertop Oven

Many toaster ovens don’t have dedicated pop-up toasters, but this model does. As such, it is a 2-in-1 countertop oven with a long slot toaster for your slices of bread. Due to this toaster design, this kitchen appliance toasts slices of bread 40% faster. And that translates to energy efficiency for reduced monthly energy bills.

What’s more, the toaster slot is large, allowing you to fit larger bread slices. As a result, you can also toast bagels in the pop up toaster on the unit’s top side. Of course, this toaster oven includes a separate toast shade selector. You can use this selector to choose your perfect shade on the toasted bread slices.

But this toaster oven features only fewer cooking functions: bake, broil, and toast. It is a basic kitchen appliance that isn’t very versatile. But it delivers one of the best toasts given its separate toast selector and pop up toaster. And that makes it a toaster oven worth buying for your kitchen.

The spacious cooking interior is large enough to fit a 9-inch pizza. With two rack positions, you will use the toasting and baking functions to prepare meals with your desired doneness level. Whether you’re looking to make muffins, potatoes, or casseroles, this toaster oven is versatile enough to cook your foods.

Safety is another well-thought-out feature. And once the 60-timer is complete, your toaster oven shuts itself down automatically. And in the end, you will be reducing the overall energy cost and reduce possible accidents. And if you want to bake for over one hour, the Stay-On feature will come in handy. This toaster oven also comes with all the accessories you need to enjoy a perfectly roasted bird. The removable accessories include a baking pan, oven rack, and a crumb tray.

ProsCons
Extra-wide toaster slot.It has no air fry function.
40% faster toasting.The heating elements are not very durable.
Separate toast shade selector.
Best Toaster Oven Reviews

GE Digital Air Fry 8-in-1 Toaster Oven

This next kitchen appliance combines a toaster oven with an air fryer in one unit. As such, it also performs the functions of air fryers. Since it combines the functions of two kitchen appliances in one unit, you can be sure to get more performance from your toaster oven.

And with a combination of two kitchen appliances, you get eight cooking programs. These cooking programs include air fry, bake, broil, convection, warm, proof, roast, and toast. As a result, you can be sure to meet all your cooking needs if you invest in this multi-functional kitchen appliance.

Controlling this unit is a lot easier than you might anticipate, thanks to the digital control panel. The control panel also includes an LCD screen for displaying your set temperature and cooking function. Therefore, you will set a precise time and temperature with the help of this HD screen.

The cooking capacity is as impressive as the capacities of full size ovens. Therefore, you don’t need to invest in a full size oven that might be more expensive without giving you the same versatility as this toaster oven. You will bake a 12-inch pizza and warm your frozen foods in the spacious cooking interior.

You can also roast an 8 lbs. chicken using the air fry function for a full-size family meal. The air fry function promotes healthy living as it uses up to 95% less oil to give the same result as the deep fry function. And with the convection mode activated, thanks to one of the best convection fans, your toaster oven becomes more energy-efficient by reducing the cooking times. The convection mode also uniformly toasts your bread slices for excellently browned toasts. Therefore, this is a kitchen appliance worth buying.

ProsCons
Air fry function.It doesn’t heat beyond 400°F.
Convection mode.Unresponsive customer support.
Large cooking capacity.
Best Toaster Oven Reviews

Mueller Austria Toaster Oven 4 Slice

This toaster oven by Mueller Austria yields one of the best toasts because it features the EvenToast Technology. The interior cooking space boasts a design that accommodates four slices of bread besides guiding heat evenly across the surfaces of the bread slices. And this results in evenly toasted bread slices.

The cooking interior is also spacious enough to bake a 9-inch pizza. This might not seem much, but the toaster oven is suitable for medium-size families. The cooking capacity is small, obviously, but the toaster oven remains one of the most versatile kitchen appliances.

And that’s because it features four cooking programs: Toast, bake, broil and keep warm settings. With all these cooking functions at your service, you can toast garlic bread and make your favorite muffins, among other foods. The toaster oven features dual rack positions.

The high and low oven rack positions could create enough room for broiling or baking your meals. The unit is similar to many convection ovens as it saves up to 60% of the energy. As such, it is yet another energy-efficient toaster oven to buy for your kitchen. You can also be sure to reduce the cooking time by 30% when toasting bread with this toaster oven. It has everything you need to enjoy evenly toasted bread slices. As such, it is one of the best appliances for toasting bread.

ProsCons
1100W cooking power.It has fewer cooking functions.
Energy-efficient.It burns some foods.
Auto shutoff feature.
Best Toaster Oven Reviews

How Do You Choose the Best Toaster Oven for Making the Best Toast?

When looking to invest in a toaster oven that makes some of the best toasts, you will ensure a few features are on the list. Once you’ve checked all the boxes with the must-have features, you can proceed to buy the toaster oven you’re eyeing. Check if your preferred toaster oven has the following features before buying it:

EvenToast Technology

Toaster ovens featuring the EvenToast technology optimize the interior heat and distribute it evenly within the interior cooking space. As a result, the toaster oven toasts the bread slices 30% more evenly than regular toaster ovens.

Since this incredible technology increases the toasting results, you should pick toaster ovens featuring it. You can read the descriptions and specification details to know if your preferred toaster oven has the EvenToast Technology.

Cooking Power

After ensuring the toaster oven you’re eyeing has the EvenToast Technology, you should also ensure it cooks with sufficient power. Knowing the cooking power of a toaster oven is easy. You only have to check its wattage rating to know how much power the toaster oven uses to cook meals.

A toaster oven with a higher wattage rating is more powerful than a toaster oven with a lower wattage rating. For example, a 1,800W toaster oven is more powerful than a 1,500W toaster oven. You want to pick a more powerful toaster oven as it preheats faster, significantly cutting the overall cooking time.

As such, you will prepare a meal for the hungry guests within a short time. Also, high wattage toaster ovens tend to produce more heat for cooking your food excellently. Therefore, consider buying more powerful toaster ovens from the market.

Cooking Capacity

The best toaster oven also cooks a meal for the whole family at once. Since you’re looking to toast slices of bread, you should pick a toaster oven capable of toasting more slices of bread. Of course, your cooking needs might vary. Sometimes, you might need to toast bread slices for one person. But other days, you might have special guests, and you need to treat them to tasty and excellently browned slices of bread.

As such, you want to go for a toaster oven capable of toasting more slices of bread. You can check the number of bread slices a toaster oven can toast and know its cooking capacity. A unit with a large cooking capacity toasts more bread slices than a toaster oven with a small cooking capacity.

A toaster oven that toasts six slices of bread at once is a perfect choice. Such a toaster oven could serve a whole family and cook a larger pizza. When picking a toaster oven for toasting slices of bread, ensure it can toast up to six bread slices at once.

Durability

Buying a toaster oven is an investment like many other investments. And like all investments, a toaster oven should serve you for many years. But durability depends heavily on the material of use for constructing the toaster oven. Manufacturers use a few materials for constructing toaster ovens.

Stainless steel is the most durable material, and toaster ovens featuring it in their design last longer. Some toaster ovens even have a hard plastic housing enclosing the stainless steel for protection against heat. As long as a toaster oven features stainless steel in its design, it will serve you for an extended period. Therefore, pick toaster ovens that are stainless steel-made.

Temperature Range

You also want to pick a toaster oven that generates sufficient heat for toasting bread slices excellently. Since you will use a toaster oven for cooking other food types other than toasting bread, you want to pick a toaster oven covering a wide temperature range.

Any unit heating from 150°F to 500°F is an excellent toaster oven. With a wide temperature range, you can cook all foods since foods have different temperature needs. Manufacturers usually write the temperature range on the temperature control dial. Even if your toaster oven uses digital buttons, you can still test it to see how far it goes as far as the temperature range goes. Therefore, only pick a toaster oven with a wide temperature range for unmatched usage versatility.

Safety Features

Kitchen appliances such as a toaster oven use electricity to function. Since they use electricity to function, they could potentially cause accidents if they lack safety features. Such accidents could include fire hazards if left to operate unmonitored. But with safety features, kitchen appliances are safer than many electrical appliances.

A toaster oven with an automatic shutoff will switch itself off once the timer countdown is complete. As a result, the toaster oven saves energy since it will switch itself off if you forgot to switch it off. Therefore, check to see your toaster oven has an automatic shutoff to prevent potential accidents in the kitchen.

Also, the handle should boast a cool-touch design. If the handle also becomes hot like the rest of the toaster oven, you could suffer serious burns. And to avert any accident, look for a toaster oven with cool-touch handles.

Easy Operation

The best toaster oven for making exceptional toast is also easy to operate. With only three control dials, you can be sure to operate a toaster oven with ease. One control dial will control the temperature, while the other two dials control the cooking functions and the cooking time.

Even if a toaster oven features digital controls, it is still easy to operate. You only have to touch the one-touch buttons to select a cooking function or set the time and temperature. Knowing a toaster oven that is easy to use is easy. If the controls are straightforward, the toaster oven is easy to operate. Therefore, take your time and pick a unit with straightforward controls for easy operation.

Ease of Cleaning

After toasting slices of bread or cooking a meal for guests, cleaning the toaster oven before storing it is the next step. But you want to have an easy time cleaning your kitchen appliance. If you desire to clean a toaster oven with ease, look for a unit with a non-stick coating.

FAQs

Can I power a toaster oven from a normal wall socket?

Yes, you could plug a toaster oven into an ordinary socket if it comes with a standard plug. Usually, these kitchen appliances draw less than 2000W from the socket, and normal sockets can withstand this load. Therefore, you can power a toaster oven from a normal wall socket.

How many cooking functions does a toaster oven have?

Toaster ovens usually feature four cooking functions. But some feature as many as thirteen cooking functions. These are more versatile as they can cook many food types. Manufacturers always list all the available cooking programs in a toaster oven. Therefore, it is easy to tell how many cooking functions a toaster oven has.

Can I clean a toaster oven with a dishwasher?

You can only clean some of the removable accessories with a dishwasher. But the toaster oven will require you to clean it by hand. Only the oven rack is dishwasher-safe. Other accessories such as the crumb tray and baking pan might not be dishwasher-safe, and you will clean them by hand.

The same goes for the main unit, the toaster oven. You will use a soft sponge to wipe the interiors clean. You might also use dish soap, but you will gently scrub the inner surfaces and wipe off the soap with a clean, damp cloth.

What is EvenToast Technology?

Toaster ovens with EvenToast Technology deliver a more uniform toast. And that is because this technology optimizes the interior heat to toast the bread slices from all directions. As a result, the browning on your bread slices will be uniform, no matter the toast shade you’ve selected.

How much heat does a toaster oven generate?

The temperature range differs from one toaster oven to another model. But these kitchen appliances tend to produce heat ranging from 150°F to 450°F. You can also find other toaster ovens generating heat of up to 500°F. So, the temperature range depends on your toaster oven’s model.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Wrap Up

Toaster ovens are multi-functional kitchen appliances that toast, bake, broil, and keep any food warm. Of course, these are the essential cooking functions. You can be sure to find other cooking functions from these unsung kitchen heroes. Besides allowing you to cook different meals, they are also durable to serve you for many years. As such, they are worth the investment in every aspect.

But finding the best toaster oven for the best toast experience isn’t as easy as you might imagine. There are a few features you will check before buying any toaster oven from the market. Fortunately, we have looked at these essential features. We have also looked at some of the best-performing toaster ovens on the market. Therefore, finding a unit that toasts your bread how you like it is easier than before. Invest in a toaster oven that makes the best toast and treat everyone to tasty toast!

Leave a Reply